How to use concealer: cover the spots, not the whole face

How to use concealer: cover the spots, not the whole face

Concealer does one thing: it moves the colour of one spot closer to the skin around it. A breakout mark is redder than its neighbours and a dark circle is darker, so both are a small local difference in colour. Close the gap and the job is done. The rules are the same whatever your gender.

Three rules follow from that one job:

• Match the skin next to the spot. A concealer lighter than its surroundings turns the spot into a pale patch, which is more visible, not less.
• Use less than you think. Concealer is highly pigmented, so a little goes a long way, and laid on thick it becomes a patch stuck to the face. One brand guide says overdoing it ends up highlighting the spot.
• Blend only the edge. The edge joins the patch to the skin. The centre stays untouched, so the coverage holds.

Everything else is not concealer’s job. The colour of the whole face belongs to foundation (section 4), and light and shadow are in highlight and contour basics and contouring for your face shape.

Shade, amount and blending, step by step

Choose the shade first.

• For breakout marks, redness and brown spots, match the skin right beside the spot. Do not test on the back of your hand or wrist. Swipe a line along your jaw, step to a window and see whether its edge disappears in daylight. A shade that matched under a lamp often changes by the window.
• Undertone: one guide says golden or yellow skin suits yellow or peach bases, and pink skin suits neutral or rosy ones. That comes from a brand guide, so treat it as a starting point and let the vanishing edge decide.
• Under the eyes is the exception. Two brand guides say one to two shades lighter than your skin. The next section says why.

Then five steps.

1. Cleanse and moisturise, add sunscreen in the daytime, and wait until the skin no longer feels tacky. On dry skin, concealer sinks into fine lines. See the basic skincare routine.
2. Take a dot about the size of a grain of rice, or less, on a small brush tip or a clean fingertip and place it on the spot, covering the spot and the ring of redness around it. No guide I found gives an exact amount. “A grain of rice” is my own rule of thumb.
3. Tap around the outer edge. A ring finger (lightest pressure), a small brush or a slightly damp sponge all work. Pat, do not drag, because dragging lifts the layer you just laid down. Leave the centre alone.
4. Wait a few seconds and look. If it is not enough, add another dot just as small. Build in thin layers instead of one thick coat.
5. Set with powder only where skin creases or turns shiny, and use very little.

The guides list all three tools, a ring finger, a small brush and a slightly damp sponge, and what they share is patting, not dragging.

Try it on your own photo. Take a bare-faced photo first: daytime, facing a window, room lights off, phone propped at eye height 1.5–2 m away, rear camera, 3–10 s timer, filters off. Then put concealer only on the spots and change nothing else. Stand in the same place at the same window and take a second photo. Zoom to 100% and look at the edge of each spot, then run both photos through the face report and see how the skin dimension reads in each. The report reads the whole photo, so a few spots may barely move it. That is a reading too, not a failure.

Dark circles, breakout marks, redness: shadow or colour?

Dark under-eyes come in more than one kind. A 2016 dermatology review sorts them into pigment in the skin, vessels showing through thin lower-lid skin, and shadow cast by a hollow beneath the eye. Shadow changes with the light: overhead light makes the under-eye darker. The review also describes a simple check. Gently stretch the lower lid flat. Pigment stays the same; shadow fades or disappears.

That difference decides what to do:

For the dark, red edge beside the nostril, one Japanese beauty site covers it with a yellow concealer first; see nose contour for your nose shape. Under-eye shadow is about light, so get the light right first: face a window, switch off the ceiling lamp, as in the overhead-light part of uneven skin in photos, then think about concealer.

Colour correction, honestly. Correcting is a makeup convention: opposite colours on the colour wheel cancel, so green goes on redness and peach or orange on blue veins. A 2016 column by two dermatologists in a trade publication sets out a chart by hue and skin depth: for redness, green on lighter skin and a yellow-based shade on deeper skin; for blue veins, peach on lighter skin and orange on deeper; brown pigment is the hardest, and the deeper it is the greyer it looks. The column cites no tests, and I found no controlled study of whether colour correction works. Even the colour for dark circles is not agreed: a nonprofit makeup guide uses pink for pink-blue circles and peach for purple-brown ones, while the column uses a yellow-based shade for purple circles on lighter skin. So treat it as a convention worth trying: put it only on the most strongly coloured spot, in a thin layer, cover it with a concealer that matches the skin, then check by a window.

Do you need foundation, powder or a tinted cream?

Not necessarily. Foundation handles the base colour over a large area and concealer handles points. When the colour of your face is already close to even and only a few spots stand out, covering the spots is enough. One guide says it plainly: on a minimal day, use concealer only where needed, blend the edges into bare skin, then set.

If you do use foundation, the order is where guides disagree. Two brand guides say foundation first, because it evens the base and so you need less concealer; the nonprofit’s guide says concealer first, foundation after. I find foundation first steadier, for the same reason of amount: once the base is down, you can see where one more dot is needed.

Powder sets; it does not colour. Press a little on the places that crease or shine, under the eyes and around the nostrils, and use less than you think; a guide notes that too much powder makes creases show. Skip it if your skin is dry. Cream products go on before powder and powder products after, the same order as for highlighter and shading.

A tinted cream, the kind that adds a little colour, belongs with foundation as long as you spread it over a whole area. It adjusts the colour of the area and cannot cover a single point. If the spot is still there, add a dot of concealer on it. Beyond the base, lip colour and edges are a separate method; see lip makeup for your lip shape.

In photos: window light, flash and zooming in

Compare cheeksForehead

I found no study of how concealer reads in photos. What follows is makeup guidance plus ordinary optics, not experimental results.

Window light. Match the shade in daylight and shoot comparison photos at the same window. When two kinds of light mix, one cheek turns yellow and the other blue and you cannot judge the shade; see uneven skin in photos.

Flash. Direct flash can bounce off reflective ingredients and show up as a white cast, called flashback. Sources disagree about the cause. One brand names zinc oxide and titanium dioxide used for sun protection in concealer and foundation, plus silica in powders. A chemistry PhD photographed a batch of powders herself: the whitest was the one high in silica, while sunscreen creams with zinc oxide and titanium dioxide were mostly fine. Her test was small and informal. Their practical advice is close: fewer reflective products, and before an event shoot a test photo with flash while wearing the makeup, which she calls the most reliable check. The brand adds that a concealer shade that is too light adds to the white cast.

Zooming in. What disappears at phone size shows at 100%: a ring around the edge of the spot, powder caught in pores, fine lines under the eyes. To know whether the concealer landed, zoom in. Skin-smoothing filters erase covered and uncovered spots alike, so turn them off for the comparison.

What research says: even colour rates better, but nobody tested concealer alone

This picks up the thread of even skin tone. A 2007 study had 353 raters score 170 crops of female cheek skin, skin only, with no features visible. The more even the colour, the more attractive and healthy the skin was rated, with correlations above 0.40. Keep four limits in mind: it measured bare skin, not skin with makeup; it covered only female skin; it was correlational, not an experiment; and the first author worked in the beauty division of a consumer-goods company.

Two studies looked at whole-face makeup. In 2011, 25 women were photographed bare and in three looks from very light to heavy. The raters were all North American. Even the lightest look was rated more attractive, by about 0.4 to 0.5 points on a 7-point scale, and heavier looks more. The change that was measured was in eye and lip contrast; skin luminance did not differ between looks and evenness was not measured. The study was funded by a consumer-goods company’s beauty division. A 2016 study compared professionally applied makeup with the face itself: cosmetics explained 25% to 33% of the variation in ratings, but the face explained more, 43% to 45%. For self-applied makeup an earlier study found only about 2%.

Together they support only this: even colour is one cue raters pick up on skin; makeup raises ratings on average, and a light look raises them less; and in the 2016 study the biggest variable was still the face itself. None of them tested covering a few spots. My inference, not a finding: if evenness is a cue, covering the most strongly coloured spots goes along with it. Nobody has tested that step.

The most common mistakes

• A shade too light, laid on thick. The spot becomes a bright patch. Switch to the matching shade and use a grain-of-rice dot.
• Dragging it on. That pulls up the layer underneath and loses the coverage. Pat instead.
• Covering the whole face. The job is the spots. The colour of the whole area is foundation’s.
• Too much powder. The lines under the eyes show more.
• Unclean tools. A dermatologists’ association advises washing brushes with soap and water every 7 to 10 days, not sharing makeup or tools, and removing all makeup, eye makeup included, before bed. If you break out easily, choose products labelled non-comedogenic.
• Covering a spot that needs a doctor. A spot that is new, changing in size or colour, sore, or that will not heal is a question for a dermatologist. Concealer hides colour; it does not deal with the spot.

FAQ

Related articles